should I keep these cheap boots?

I finally made it in to Reading to return the shirts I bought the bf for Christmas and walked away with two pairs of boots. WHY can I only buy footwear in grous of two or three, not just a pair at a time? Added to the boots I got from Camden on Sunday that is three pairs this week. Despair. However, I need help deciding if I should keep these. Pair number one:


Pros: Have wanted boots like these since 2008 when I worked on Kurt Geiger and mega expensive mega lush ones came in. They have a high platform heel which makes them comfy. They give me the required height to wear these Alice Cooper slashed leggings which my legs may or may not be too porky for. They were only £12.50

Cons: Have wanted boots like this since 2008 = not hot anymore! I may break my neck in them. They are pleather, perhaps a bit too cheap looking?


Pair number 2:


Sure they're pretty hideous but they don't look that bad in real life, were only £11 and sometimes you need cheap boots so that you don't destroy your precious expensive boots. And for good measure, here are the Camden boots, £15: